Sign Up   Log In

Show featured first » Jeff The Killer Love Story x 

Jeff The Killer Love Story Quizzes

Your Creepypasta Admirer! *Long Results* by Jewel of White

The title says it all! Long results too! Including Slendy, Jeffy, LJ, EJ, BEN, and Ticci Toby!

Slendy, LJ, Jeff, Ben, or Toby? // Creepypasta lover by Alanna

Figure out which creepypast out of Ben, Slendy, Laughing Jack, Ticci Toby, or Jeff the killer, would be your lover! This is a little late but it's in honor of creepypasta day! *Does a small dance* Okay lets gooo!~

Your Creepypasta Boyfriend! by stay bloody

Yes, i know this is not unique, but i really like these so i figured, why not make one. Guys can take this too , im not just limiting girls.

Does Jeff the Killer Like You? by Jeff the Killer

· Scary
What's the best psychotic murder ever's opinion on you?

Creepypasta: Seven Minutes in Heaven by The Winged Kestrel

· Scary
Yeah, this one sucks. I kind of rushed it. Oh well. I don't really mind. I hope you guys enjoy it. Possible results are Jeff the Killer, BEN Drowned, Slenderman, Masky, Hoody, Ticci Toby, Eyeless Jack, and Laughing Jack. Have fun.

Whose your lover? [Creepypasta x Reader] by נα є нαяℓєу

... Well, results are long-ish, and they're Jeff, Masky and Hoodie, Slenderman, BEN Drowned, Eyeless Jack, and Laughing Jack ^^' (Will be called LJ) *Note* Females only. .w. Sorry guys.

Which CreepyPasta loves you? by Zaliagh

· Humor
It's in the title cx

Which Creepypasta is your lover 2!

I'm baaaack.Since the first quiz was such a huge hit,I decided to make one with the less popular Creepypasta guys.Who do you have?It may not be as good as the first because you may not like the results but it includes Rake,Zalgo,Skin Taker,Brvr,Bloody Painter,Offenderman,Trenderman,Lost Silver,a...

7 Minutes In Heaven (Creepypasta Edition!)

Hello,Jayla here! I'm new here, and so is this quiz! What sexy boy from the Creepypasta gang would love you? Oh, I almost forgot, don't kill me because it sucked...Oh, and if enough comments are posted about it, I'll make a story about you and your Creepypasta boyfriend!

Creepypasta lovers!~ by BASSIE

· Scary
You have the choices out of Jeff, Liu, BEN, Ticci Toby, The twins, EJ, LJ, and last but not least Jane the killer +Sally (for bi or les also if you don't like that then you can suck jeff's balls!)

7 mins in heaven with the Creepypastas by Hell's Angel

WARNING SOME RESULTS ARE GRAFFIC OMG over 3000 takers thank you all! Be sure to take the other quiz's - Spin the bottle with the creepypastas

Your creepypasta love story (sleepover)

Includes truth or dare, 7 minutes in heaven, sleepover, and boyfriend.

Jeff the killer... by Silveria

· Scary
He wants you to be his (special somebody) on valentines day!

Do the proxy twins like you?

All in the title bro :3 All pictures belong to their rightful owners lol heres the Ocs and some of one of the results Kitty invited you to the creepy pasta house its actually pretty funny here. Jeff always running from Jane. Avril (killer) protecting Jeff. BEN and Niki (ghost) Chillin and playi...

Seven Minutes in Heaven! (Creepypasta ) by с н α м ε l ε ο η. χ

Hey, killers do it better xD , it's all in the title lovelies. :3

Creepypasta Love Time ( Long Results) by J.A.G.L

Come on the title explains everything. Okay I know there are more but it's late and this took me a really long time to even think about so don't comment " There are more pastas." I know that but I will edit to make soon. There is Swearing in the results.

Jeff The Killer Love Story Stories

Mαу тнє bєѕт mαη wιη (reader x creepypasta various) by ƇιєƖ Ƥнαηтσмнινє

102 pages · Horror · Romance
"She's mine all of you back off she may not know that I love her but she will be all mine someday." -Jeff "I want more than her kidneys. I want her heart." -E.J "None of you better touch her. She is mine if any of you idiots touch her it will be game over for you all." ...

Just A Glitch | BEN Drowned

104 pages ~ Completed · Horror · Romance
[BEN DROWNED X READER] Your father had an opportunity to switch his job to the Apple of the world. Accepting it, your family moves into an apartment above Time Square. While running some errands for your mom, you meet a kind old man who gives you a cartridge. Yet li...

50 Shades Of Blades (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by Ticci Taylor

44 pages · Romance · Fan Fiction · Anime/Manga
(Yeah I know there are thousands of these....) The creepypastas have gotten on Slendy's last nerves, so he decides he is going to punish them by sending them to the one place every teenager dreads, high school! There they meet (Y/N), Slenderman's supposed niece. Jeff takes an interest in her...

Trick And Kill~Jeff The KillerXReaderXEyeless Jack by Raphaelia

147 pages · Thriller · Fan Fiction
Madness knows no limits. The same goes for love~~ A Jeff The KillerXReaderXEyeless Jack fanfiction

This Feeling

84 pages ~ Completed · Romance · Horror
[Reader x Jeff the killer] You just moved into a new town, for a fresh start. All is good during the day, the tranquility of the neighborhood makes you feel welcome. During the night is a different story.

ςЯAzㄚin love || Jeff The Killer by ᎥᏞᎾᏉᎬᏢᎪᏁᎠᎪs

80 pages · Romance · Fan Fiction
~ Readers insert ~ You thought that this would work but it only pissed Jeff off more. He growled and in a swift movement you were in his arms, knife pressed against your neck. Your mother gasped and clamped her hands to her mouth, dropping the bat. “I’ll tell you what’s going on, girlie,” ...

What Lies Beneath (Ticci Toby) by Shauna

136 pages · Mystery · Fan Fiction
River, once a witch, has thrown away everything to become stronger to protect her new family. Upon making a deal with Vixton, a powerful reaper, River is stripped of her title and made into a reaper. No longer being just River, she now is a leader to an elite group of reapers and is know simply as &...

You're My Jinx ~Jeff the Killer~[COMPLETED]

134 pages ~ Completed · Romance · Horror
I stared into the unblinking eyes of a psychotic killer. Face to face. "Oh, but you love me, Jeff." I smirked. "Say anymore and I'll put this knife right through your throat." He threatened. "You won't hurt me. You can't." I smiled to myself. "Don't jinx yourself." He got close to me. ...

Slenderman's Little Red Riding Hood. by Ƙιкι ιѕ α ρυмρкιη.ˣ

45 pages · Mystery · Thriller
[Ticci Toby x reader] [Y/N] was a bright girl. She loved everyone, she made everyone smile. She wasn't the type of little girl to misbehave. This child was only 5 years old. Her parents didn't seem like the type to abuse her. But of course never judge a book by its cover. So what happens w...

Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios by Midnight Bliss

81 pages · Fan Fiction · Horror
Loved reading these, and decided to do my own :3 Includes, Jeff, BEN, EJ, Masky, Hoodie, Slenderman, and moreee Enjoy~~

Innocents Lure (Jeff The Killer Love Story)

130 pages ~ Completed · Action · Romance
A young girl who sees a light through all darkness, captures the heart of possibly one of the most darkest hearts out there. And all with a simple action.

I'm in Love with a Killer [Jeff the Killer x Reader] by THEcutie20

36 pages ~ Completed · Romance · Fan Fiction
(Y/n) had always been abused by her father, and had been bullied at school. To her, her life was depressing. She even attempt on suicide. But what will happen when a certain serial killer enters her life?