He gave you a bunch of roses and gave you a small teddy bear.
He gave you a (human) heart and a box full of chocolates.
Both of you played video games all day and watched Grown Ups.
Jeff the Killer
Let you have a major killing head start and wrote "I Love You" in blood.
He gave you your very own Pokemon and it was a Pikachu!
He gave you a sweet kiss on the cheek and he gave you a necklace that has your favorite color.
He took you to your favorite place and he actually enjoyed it! Ticci Toby
He gave you a cute necklace with a smiling waffle and you two watched movies with a sweet kiss on the cheek.
He gave you a small puppy and you named him Snickers. (Yes, like the chocolate bar )
He gave you a lightning bolt necklace and played Pokémon X and Y with you.